The Complete Thin Man Collection
MGM (1934-1947)
Blu-ray: Warner Archive $49.98
This phenomenally popular detective series, the finest “A” movie detective series of its time, is available in an economically priced collection that brings together all six of the films plus a delicious array of vintage shorts from the year each film was released. Based on the 1934 Dashiell Hammett novel, impeccable casting as Nick and Nora Charles, and with expert W.S. Van Dyke direction on the first four films, The Complete Thin Man Collection should find a spot on a multitude of movie lovers’ shelves.
The Thin Man (1934) launched the series to great critical and popular acclaim, including an Academy Award™ Best Picture nomination. William Powell is Nick Charles, famous detective and underworld hobnobber who retired on his laurels when he married uber-rich high society heiress Nora, Myrna Loy. He gets drawn back into the mystery-solving racket when a friend of the family turns up missing and the man’s daughter (Maureen O’Sullivan) presses Nick to find her father, the “thin man” of the title. Nat Pendleton, Cesar Romero, Harold Huber, Edward Brophy, and of course Asta the dog co-star.
Bonuses:
The Thin Man TV series 1958 episode “Scene of the Crime” with Peter Lawford, Phyllis Kirk, and a different Asta
Lux Radio Theater presentation of The Thin Man with Powell & Loy, 1936
Original Theatrical Trailer (Philo Vance meets Nick Charles; both were portrayed by Powell in separate film series)
After the Thin Man (1936) is, in this reviewer’s opinion, even better and one of the funniest comedies of the 1930s. Set immediately after the events in the previous film, Nick and Nora return home to San Francisco from their New York adventure and discover that Nora’s cousin’s husband has gone missing, and another mystery is afoot. James Stewart, Joseph Calleia, Sam Levene, and Penny “Blondie” Singleton (billed under her real name, Dorothy McNulty) co-star – with Asta, naturally. Nora’s family – who don’t approve of her marriage – are a scream.
Bonuses:
How to be a Detective (top-notch 1-reeler with Robert Benchley)
Cartoon: The Early Bird and the Worm
Lux Radio Theatre presentation with Powell & Loy, 1940
Radio promo
Trailer
Another Thin Man (1939) is nearly as good, despite the arrival of the quite unnecessary toddler Nick Charles Jr. This time, the business partner of Nora’s late father has been receiving death threats, and when they turn out to be much more than idle, the hunt is on. C. Aubrey Smith, Otto Kruger, Virginia Grey, Tom Neal, Patric Knowles, Sheldon Leonard, and Shemp Howard (and Asta) co-star.
Million-dollar Dialog:
Nick, telling Nora she was easy to spot in a crowd: “I knew there was only one woman in the world who could attract men like that. One with a lot of money."
Bonuses:
Love on Tap musical short with the Abbott Dancers
Cartoon: The Bookworm
Trailer
Shadow of the Thin Man (1941) and a relaxing outing to the racetrack for the Charleses turns into another whodunit; a crooked jockey is dead and there’s mischief and mayhem that leads to a professional wrestling scam (imagine that). Donna Reed, Stella Adler, Louise Beavers, Barry Nelson, and Asta co-star.
Bonuses:
The Tell-Tale Heart, a chilling 2-reel Poe adaptation by Jules Dassin
Hanna-Barbera MGM cartoon: The Goose Goes South
Trailer
It’s with The Thin Man Goes Home (1944) that the series finally shows its age. Myrna Loy returned to the screen (this was her only picture during the war, she was busy with volunteer work) and series director W.S. Van Dyke had died, leaving Richard Thorpe to direct. A visit to Nick’s hometown has the residents all a-buzz of the mystery he’s there to solve, and while he tries to convince them that it’s just a family vacation, sure enough, a murder victim is stumbled over and Nick’s back in action. Harry Davenport and Lucile Watson are Nick’s parents; Gloria DeHaven, Helen Vinson, Lloyd Corrigan, Leon Ames and Asta co-star. You’ll note that by this point in the series, MGM was referring to Nick himself as the “thin man.”
Bonuses:
Why Daddy? (Another wonderful Benchley short; he actually wrote this one)
Cartoon: Screwball Squirrel
Trailer
Song of the Thin Man (1947) ended the series on a somewhat low note, directed by Edward Buzzell. The murder of a popular musician draws Nick back into one last web of suspense and laughs. Gloria Grahame, Jayne Meadows, Asta, and – as Nick Jr. – Dean Stockwell co-star.
Bonuses:
Passing Parade: A Really Important Person
Cartoon: Slap Happy Lion
Trailer
Witty, with off-the-charts chemistry between Powell & Loy, The Complete Thin Man Collection is sure to be a timeless favorite. “Each film has been meticulously remastered and restored for Blu-ray, from 4K scans of the best surviving elements,” Warner Archive advises, and yes, on the features, the meticulous remastering absolutely lights up the screen. This set is a keeper and the first three in the series will be pulled down a lot when friends come over and want to be treated to a “good old movie." They're amongst my go-to offerings on movie nights.
"Wonderful! Nick was sober in Kansas City."