Bonnie Scotland

Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (1935) Dir. James W. Horne
81 min. / B&W / 1.37:1 / DTS-HD MA 2.0 MONO / SDH

Warner Archive BD $24.98
Available from our partner Movie Zyng

A few years ago, the first time I ever had the opportunity to speak with George Feltenstein, the Warner Archive legend, I put in a good word for a restored Blu-ray with one of the Laurel & Hardy features WB now owns via its acquisition of the MGM library, and discovered Mr. F is, like me, a proud Son of the Desert. I was confident that the Archive would come through, and here we are, a 1935 feature that benefits tremendously from its beautiful presentation.

“Stan McLaurel” and Oliver Hardy stowaway aboard a cattle boat because Stan has inherited a Scottish estate that turns out to be a set of bagpipes and a snuff box. Enduring the usual slapstick setbacks, they end up joining the foreign legion and the rest of the picture is a parody, more or less, of The Lives of a Bengal Lancer.

I don’t (and can’t) imagine anyone familiar with prime Laurel & Hardy that doesn’t love them, so I’m going to assume you’re all on board, dear readers. As good as some of their features are (and some truly are marvelous), it is their 2- and 3-reel short subjects that showcase their best work, and features like Bonnie Scotland can be edited, cut down, and re-released as short subjects (which is exactly what became of Bonnie Scotland back in the day). Enjoying this film today in full 80 min. version, well, once you’ve seen it, there’s no reason not to fast forward through the subplot with young lovers June Lange and the charmless William Janney and get right to Stan, Babe, and Jimmy Finlayson and their antics. These sequences are some of the best the team ever did, with surprises galore and many laugh-out-loud moments, starting with their entrance in the film, in which Lionel Belmore as the village blacksmith suddenly commences to pound out “The Cuckoo Song” on his anvil. Their theme pops up again later in the film when the Legionnaires play it on their bagpipes during a march! You’ll also find funny sequences in a boarding room (naturally) and a dance routine with the boys in the fort and in the grand scheme of things this isn’t one of the greatest films, but enjoying it on the sparkling Blu-ray from Warner Archive, it didn’t seem far away from one. The polish MGM gave these films – wonderful sets and supporting characters – is appreciated by us (and probably was by Hal Roach, too).

Bonus material carried over from the DVD includes the Boys’ guest sequences from Hollywood Party and Pick a Star, totaling about very funny 20 minutes, and one of my all-time favorite commentary tracks, with Leonard Maltin and Richard Bann. The trailer is included, and claims the film is “60 minutes of joy,” which means they apparently didn’t think the remaining 20 min. was very joyful, so take that into consideration.

I will never not want to spend time with Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy and any of their pre-1940 films, and a beautiful restoration that makes Bonnie Scotland – more than 90 years old! – look this good makes it one of the most cherished releases of the year so far.

Gee, I'm dumb today!”