A Midsummer Night's Dream

Warner Bros. (1935) Dir. Prof. Max Reinhardt & William Dieterle
143 min. / B&W / 1.37:1 / DTS-HD MA 2.0 MONO / SDH

Warner Archive BD $24.98
Available from our partner Movie Zyng

Hermia and Lysander are madly in love, but her father has ordered her to marry Demetrius instead, whom she absolutely doesn’t love. The local Duke – arbitrator of such things – offers her an out: she can become a nun instead. Lysander and Hermia think that's a bad deal, so they run off into the woods to get married, Demetrius in hot pursuit, and hot on HIS heels is Helena, whose unrequited love for Demetrius could fill the play all by itself.

In these woods, however, there is magic afoot: the King and Queen of faeries, Oberon and Titania, have been arguing over possession of a changeling and so Oberon hatches a half-assed plan to make everybody fall in love with everybody else through the use of a magical flower applied to their eyes by his giddy henchman, the diminutive Robin “Puck” Goodfellow (and no, I didn't spell that wrong, his name is PUCK) but he pucks it up and the wrong people fall in love, and by the way, there's a group of very, very bad actors, not in this film, necessarily, but in the plot: they're planning to do a play for the Duke on the occasion of his wedding in order to win a prize, but the leading man's an ass, and I don't mean that the way you think I do: he's been turned into one by Puck, another magical event on this night of nights. Not only that, but Titania got some o' that stuff in her eyes and now she really, really wants a piece of THAT ass. Can we possibly get all this straightened out in, um, only 2 hours and 23 minutes?

Well, I think it's safe to say that nobody saw anything like THIS before (or since), a hit 1934 stage production (live from the Hollywood Bowl) that the Brothers Warner turned into one of the all-time weirdest things I've ever seen, bar none. It makes Hal Roach's production of Babes in Toyland look tame; it makes Paramount's ungodly grotesque Alice in Wonderland look, well, not so grotesque in comparison. Most of it was shot through shimmering spider webs, and there are dozens of dancers and flying pixies and gremlins everywhere you look, occasionally interrupted by some of our favorite Hollywood stars, including one in her film debut. Let's see if we can sort this all out.

Whom and what we liked...

Olivia de Havilland (Hermia) was still in her teens and making her film debut and she's lovely and seems to have serious affection for...

Dick Powell (Lysander), who got bad reviews when this came out but what th' heck, I thought he was okay, mainly because he’s so funny when paired with…

Ross Alexander (Demetrius), who is terrific, and since I also just saw him and thought him wonderful in Flirtation Walk, I'm thinkin' that I need to get to know this guy's films better. (I know he died young.)

James Cagney (Bottom) wouldn't have been my choice; Reinhardt wanted W.C. Fields, which would've been interesting, but the Great Man was over at Metro's doin' Dickens. Second choice was Guy Kibbee, but he was replaced by Cagney, who is as far as you can get from Fields or Kibbee, obviously, and while he’s a far cry from Shakespeare’s Bottom, so to speak, it’s still great fun to see Cagney in the role.

Victor Jory (Oberon) practically steals the picture; best thing I've ever seen him do, and in his Faerie King outfit he looks, of all things, like Maleficent from Sleeping Beauty!

Joe E. Brown (Flute) bothered me the first time I saw this picture; on second watch, he really grew on me.

Ian Hunter (The Duke) was born to play Shakespeare, seems like.

Music by Mendelssohn: Really, really nice score.

What we didn't like...

Mickey Rooney (Puck) got excellent reviews when the film was new; hard to see why these days, he’s intolerable, insufferable, and annoying.

Hugh Herbert (Snout) I want to punch every time he giggles.

What I didn't care about, but at least they're pretty...

Jean Muir (Helena)
Anita Louise (Titania)

Million-dollar Dialog:
Lysander to his rival: "You have her father's love, Demetrius. Let me have Hermia's. YOU marry HIM."

Incidentally, the play is one of my all-time favorites, it's one Shakespeare comedy that is still hilarious today. I don't know that I give out a lot of mixed reviews, tending to either like something, be appalled by it, or fall asleep through it, but I soared through this one with my thumb bouncing both up and down. Parts of it are wonderful and I found myself thinking that this was a film I'd trot out for rewatches, and other parts made me cringe (mostly young Master Rooney). I will admit I watched it over two nights, I think it’s a tough sell in one sitting. That said, it's not like there's a lot of film adaptations of this particular play to enjoy and it certainly is one of a kind.

The Blu-ray is a massive upgrade over the old DVD and remains packed with bonus material, headed by a 2-reeler called Shake, Mr. Shakespeare that has singing and dancing characters from the Bard's works, and is a delight, but alas is not in great shape. The rest is 1935 promotional materials with the cast (each of them apparently instructed to use the word “genius” when describing Prof. Reinhardt), a lot of fun, and a full reel of Olivia's screen tests. We also enjoyed the in-depth commentary by Scott MacQueen. Great stuff.

Oh, this is the SILLIEST stuff that ever I heard!”