Sing You Sinners*

Paramount (1939) Dir. Wesley Ruggles
91 min. / B&W / 1.37:1 / DTS Master Audio 2.0 Mono / SDH
Universal Blu-ray $21.98

Available from
Movie Zyng
As long as you can earn a nickel opening your traps, you boys are gonna do it.”

If you can’t decide whether to watch a musical, a gangster picture, a family drama, a sports movie, or a romantic comedy, have we got the movie for you: Sing You Sinners is all of ‘em.

Fred MacMurray, Bing Crosby, and li'l Donald O'Connor are three brothers still living at widowed mom's Elizabeth Patterson's house. Fred wants to marry pretty Ellen Drew, but he's the sole breadwinner in the family because Bing's a lazy ne'er do well. The three are weekend musicians at the insistence of mom, although they all hate music. One hot summer night Fred is working late and Bing makes a pass at Ellen, following that up by leaving town to seek his fortune after Fred beats him up (he deserved it). Bing settles in with a small store and does well enough to send for Ma and Donald. Alas, by the time they arrive, he's traded his job for a racehorse(!) and is broke again. So, Fred is called in, the three re-form their musical trio, and they scrape up enough money in tips to feed the horse and install him in – what else – the Big Race, with O'Connor as the novice jockey(!!!). Well, some gangster threaten the kid, and... Oh, forget it.

It's a Crosby musical, folks, get over the plot and get on to the songs.

The big numbers here are Pocketful of Dreams and - and this shocked the hell out of me - Small Fry, the song that I know by heart from the wonderful Max Fleischer cartoon. No idea it came from a Bing Crosby film (nor did I know it was written by Hoagy Carmichael and Frank Loesser).

The main problem with this film has always been that Bing is so unlikeable, a change of pace for him of course but doesn’t make for easy viewing when you'd rather seem him as a singing priest or playing patty-cake with Bob Hope. Nobody has ever blamed Fred for decking him in this picture. As for the precocious Donald O’Connor, he was barely 13 but acquits himself well; after all, he’d been working in vaudeville for nearly all those 13 years. Ellen Drew had a long but not very distinguished career, although we’ll always cherish her for Monster and the Girl and Isle of the Dead. And mom Elizabeth Patterson is instantly recognizable as Mrs. Trumbull, little Ricky's babysitter on I Love Lucy.

Sing You Sinners ends up as an entertaining if rather improbably time-filler, directed by Wesley Ruggles (brother of comic actor Charlie), who made some interesting pictures but isn’t much renowned amongst film historians. Ruggles went from this to a pair of Jean Arthur films to a pair of Lana Turner films and was out of the industry by the mid-1940s.

Verdict from the Balcony

A fun movie fans of Bing Crosby and Donald O’Connor will enjoy, and worth a watch for anybody else, particularly if you want to hear Fred MacMurray sing (he’s not bad). As per other Universal Vault series releases, no bonus material is include, but if you find the Small Fry cartoon online to pair it with, you've really got something!