Lili
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (1953) Dir. Charles Waters
81 min. / Technicolor / 1.37:1 / DTS: HD 2.0 Mono / SDH
Warner Archive Blu-ray $21.99

*
Available from Movie Zyng

A young French waif discovers that the baker to which her dying father sent her for shelter has himself passed, and with nowhere else to go, becomes a tagalong to a handsome carnival magician and his two friends, puppeteers on the midway. While she’s only 16, she finds plenty of wolves at her door, but Lili is infatuated with the magician – and the puppets in the show, where she’s soon a valuable cast member, interacting with the marionettes and singing the film’s theme, Hi-Lili, Hi-Lo. In fact, she gets along with everyone except one of the puppeteers, a former dancer who was crippled in the war and now hides in bitter anger behind his array of stringed friends. Will Lili discover that what she loves about the puppets actually comes from the heart of the gruff puppeteer? Maybe.

One of the most dramatic of all the MGM musicals; parts of it are borderline unendurable because Lili – an Oscar nominated role for Leslie Caron – is so mistreated by some of the men in the cast. Besides the infectious theme song (which we grew up hearing in hit cover versions by Manfred Mann and Alan Price), Miss Caron gets to show off her terpsichorean skills in a sexy number with magician Jean-Pierre Aumont and his lovely assistant Zsa Zsa Gabor(!). Yes, we said sexy – Leslie Caron was 21 when the film was made.

Our bitter puppeteer is Mel Ferrer, extremely unlikeable but the only leading member of the cast besides his buddy Kurt Kazner who can speak completely intelligible English. Amanda “Miss Kitty” Blake is one of the showgirls, though.

This was a first-time viewing for us, and while the rural French carnival setting, gorgeous in Technicolor, the charming and personable puppets, and the appealing leading lady (plus the MGM brand) suggested a frothy musical, Lili is anything but: there’s powerful drama underneath its veneer. The original story was by Paul Gallico (Pride of the Yankees, The Poseidon Adventure; the Mrs. ‘arris books), who rewrote and republished it before handing over the scripting to Helen Deutsch, who also wrote the lyrics to the song. Lili was nominated for 6 Academy Awards (including for its screenplay, director, and Miss Caron) and won for its score by Bronisław Kaper.

Leslie Caron was famously discovered by Gene Kelly; she was a ballerina in France and he mentored her into Hollywood for An American in Paris. While she’s celebrated for her musicals (including The Glass Slipper, Daddy Long Legs, and Gigi) she preferred dramatic parts (and would earn a second Oscar nomination for The L-Shaped Room in 1962). She’s still with us.

The Warner Archive edition of Lili is another beautiful achievement in restoration and will delight the numerous fans of this film, which has plenty of drama but is also appropriate for children thanks to the personable puppets. Blu-ray bonuses include a trio of MGM cartoons of the era, Tom & Jerry in the hilarious Pecos Pest and the pretty good Puppy Tale and a not-so-good Barney Bear cartoon, Impossible Possum.

We don't  learn. We just  get older, and  we know.”